Blog Entry

The Andrew Bynum injury portfolio

Posted on: October 4, 2010 11:44 am
Lakers center probably out till December, continues history of injury recovery struggles. Posted by Matt Moore

Hey there, reader. Listen, I some news to tell you. You should sit down. No, really, you should be sitting when you hear this news. I don't want your legs to give out (fittingly) when you hear this. The shock may be too much to bear. There, now. That's better. Okay, are you ready?

Andrew Bynum is pushing back his comeback date. I know, I know. It hit us all. News like that just comes out of nowhere and the surprise can be hard on the heart...

I'll stop now.

Like we gave you a heads up on in the Shootaround , Bynum spoke to reporters and pushed back his comeback to mid-December. This only days after saying November was the target . It's a typical development for Bynum, when you look back at his history.

Bynum was first injured in January of 2008, and was supposed to be out two months . Then he was not going to be back for the playoffs. Then he was . Then not so much . Then definitely not so much . Then he had more surgery .

Then he took a nap.
Then he was totally going to be back the next season. Totally. Well, okay, maybe not right on schedule . Then he had a birthday party , yay! Then he came back and looked like he was worth the hype. Then he signed a massive contract extension , making him one of the highest paid players on a team full of All-Stars and future Hall-of-Famers.

Then, he got hurt, again , this time with a torn MCL . He was supposed to be back in March from this one, then it got pushed to April . Then he finally came back in the 2009 playoffs, but could only play limited minutes. But hey, helped win them a title, so who cares? Celebrate!

Then he famously stopped working out with Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, a move that was criticized at the time, but given Kareem's lack of toughness and prickly personality, probably wasn't a bad idea. Next, Bynum had to have his knee drained in the playoffs, but, and this should be stressed, he toughed it out and helped the Lakers win a back-to-back title. He dragged that leg around though he was playing on turned out to be a slight tear, played hard, and helped the Lakers' size overwhelm their opponents. This summer, he had another surgery after he delayed it so he could go on vacation.

So what are we looking at, here? Long story short, we've got a very young kid who's shown to a. be a very slow healer and b. have a very poor work ethic. Don't take my word for it, Ask Tex Winter . The first account is something Bynum could help or should be criticized for. You can't get your body to heal faster. But you can put it in the best position to heal and bounce back as strong as you need to, and that's where Bynum struggles. He famously sloughed off the Lakers' doctors for his own. Now, that's actually probably a good idea, considering that training staff doesn't have a great history with knee injuries. But when your other doctor manages to need multiple surgeries, and you have continuing issues with recovery? There are going to be questions.

Bynum has yet to hit an initial return date. There is a history of problematic recovery issues, on knees that have had multiple surgeries. To call him injury-prone at this point is an understatement.

The good news is that the Lakers can be patient with Bynum. They have enough talent and size on that roster that even if Bynum can only give them limited minutes for years, that's fine. The question is if after this championship dynasty is over and Kobe Bryant bids a fond farewell, if Bynum will then be in a position to deserve the extension he signed. Maybe this is the last bump in the road. Maybe he'll prove to be a dominant NBA center night in and night out this season. But if he does, he'll be slipping out of a well-established history of recovery issues. It's not fair, but it's what it is.

Since: Aug 4, 2008
Posted on: October 5, 2010 5:09 pm

The Andrew Bynum injury portfolio

I am a Laker fan and always wish them well. When a player get injured it always concern be that they take care of this jury as soon as possible, not necessarily to return to help the team, though that would be one of the prime motivations to help your team mates.

I find it interesting that players with an abundant amount of talent would find ways to misuse this talent and not take advantage of what was bestowed on you or acquired through family genes.

I have seen those Laker players with great work habits and immediately take the necessary action when injured. Then there are the ones that I have seen that are not as punctual as others about getting the necessary medical things taken care of in a timely manner.

Shaq comes to mind immediately as he got injured, the comments he made was I got injured on company time, therefore I will have my medical problems and healing done on company time. This might not be the exact words, but as close as I can recall.

This is not the attitude to take in a team sport, especially one that has the reputation of
the Lakers as being winners, getting a fair to above average salary.

I suppose some have the mental attitude to accept the gift they have then the others take it for granted and do as little as possible to enhance what they have and grow to be better.

Magic and Kobe had that I want to be better and will work hard as I can to improve even on the off season and make my team better.

I don’t advocate anyone playing hurt that would be detrimental to their health and would cause permanent injury to them.

They can always take a vacation to places the average American sport fan can only fantasize about. They have friends that are politically connected and financially able to  make it possible for them to live a good life and enjoy things that are available only to a select few.

I don’t know Bynam. I would hope the work habits of Kobe and Pau would rub off on him as time advance as he might be the face of the of the franchise in the next 5-10 years.

I personally would prefer someone of the Kobe, Magic mode as to that of a Shaq mode, even with all the talent they both appear to have in abundance.



Since: Aug 21, 2006
Posted on: October 5, 2010 12:19 pm

Delayed surgery

I am a big Laker fan, but I know nothing about what kind of person Bynum is.

My concern is this:  "This summer, he after he delayed it so he could go on vacation."

You cannot help needing surgery, but if your heart is really in it then you have surgery as soon as possible to get ready for the next season.

This reminds me of Shaq's "injured on company time, gonna rehab on company time" approach and I don't like attitude.

There may be more to this story (e.g. doctor wanted Bynum's swelling reduced before surgery), but on the surface it is not good.


Since: Oct 4, 2010
Posted on: October 4, 2010 3:14 pm

The Andrew Bynum injury portfolio

Bynum is a partier. He is not motivated to work hard. I'm happy he's not. I'm a Blazer fan. Sometimes I think the really big guys are just massively laid back. Much like the short guys being overly motivated. Maybe there is an EXTREMELY TALL GUY syndrome as well!

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or